Mrs. Pike looked annoyed.
“Counsel,” she said, “if the recorded page ain’t stamped invalid, then the recorded deed ain’t stamped invalid.”
A few people in the courtroom coughed to hide laughter.
Then came the 1986 document.
A handwriting expert testified that the Walter J. Hayes signature on the deed of trust showed significant inconsistencies with verified signatures from the same period. Not absolute proof, but strong evidence.
Walter testified next.
He walked to the witness stand slowly, aware of every eye on him.
Ben asked, “Mr. Hayes, did you sign the 1986 deed of trust pledging your land as collateral for Hayes & Sons Farm Supply?”
“No, sir.”
“Did you authorize Samuel Hayes to sign for you?”
“No.”
“Did you appear before Charles Mercer for notarization?”
“No.”
“Did you know your land had been listed as collateral?”
“Not until the bank tried to take it.”
The bank’s attorney rose.
“Mr. Hayes, your uncle Samuel was family, correct?”
“Yes.”
“And families sometimes help each other?”
“Some do.”
“Isn’t it possible you signed something years ago and forgot?”
Walter looked at him.
“I forgot what I had for supper last Tuesday,” he said. “I didn’t forget signing away my farm.”
This time the judge allowed the laughter to pass before tapping her gavel.
The attorney tried again. “You admit the signature resembles yours?”
“It resembles my name. That doesn’t make it my hand.”
“Mr. Hayes, are you suggesting a respected bank officer, a notary, and your own uncle conspired against you?”
Walter leaned toward the microphone.
“I’m suggesting somebody wanted my land more than they cared about my name.”
The courtroom went still.
Then Paige Mercer testified.
She described finding the archived file, the memo, and the handwritten note. Her voice faltered when she read her grandfather’s initials aloud.
The bank’s attorney objected repeatedly.
Judge Carter overruled him repeatedly.
Ben entered the memo into evidence.
Samuel Hayes has represented that Walter J. Hayes will not cooperate…
Recommend excluding rural acreage unless Walter signs in person…
NRR says proceed…
C.M. not present at signing…
Nathan Rollins looked straight ahead, his face carved from stone.
When Paige finished, Ben asked, “Ms. Mercer, in your professional opinion, should the bank have proceeded with foreclosure after discovering these documents?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
“Because the foundational collateral instrument is seriously compromised.”
The bank’s attorney stood for cross-examination.
“Ms. Mercer, you resigned from Citizens Valley Bank, correct?”
“Yes.”
“After violating internal policy by removing documents?”
“I copied documents relevant to a potentially unlawful foreclosure.”
“That was not my question.”
“No,” Paige said. “But it was my answer.”
The courtroom murmured again.
The attorney’s mouth tightened. “Your grandfather, Charles Mercer, notarized the deed of trust.”
“His name appears on it.”
Leave a Comment